The Treble With Men (Scorned Women's Society, #2)
As far as Green Valley is concerned, Kim Dae disappeared into the Wraiths a decade ago. They were sort of right. Kim has spent her life since Jethro fighting her curious nature and trying to blend into the background. Unfortunately for her, a mysterious Maestro comes to town and takes quick notice of her for reasons unknown to anybody. The masked conductor, known simply as Devlin, was already a source of much gossip thanks to his reputation for getting fired. Now, his sudden interest in the quiet fourth chair cellist has added fuel to the rumor fire. The new conductor of the symphony needs to learn to control his temper and finish his latest musical masterpiece and only the reluctant star of his symphony can help him do that. If Devlin can’t convince Kim to help to finish his latest composition he’ll lose everything. Can Devlin and Kim compose without losing composure?

The Treble With Men (Scorned Women's Society, #2) Details

TitleThe Treble With Men (Scorned Women's Society, #2)
Author
LanguageEnglish
ReleaseApr 7th, 2020
PublisherSmartypants Romance
Rating
GenreRomance, Contemporary Romance, Contemporary

The Treble With Men (Scorned Women's Society, #2) Review

  • lazybookconqueror
    January 1, 1970
    What a masterpiece. This book is going straight to my best of 2020 list."Music was the feeling of universal understanding." The Treble with Men is a beautiful Phantom of the Opera retelling that is simply unputdownable. Kim Dae, who now goes by the stage name Christine Day, is the quiet fourth chair cellist in the SOOK. The orchestra recently hired a new maestro, the mysterious and masked Devlin is vicious in his teachings and was dubbed by his peers the Devil of the Symphony.When Devlin approac What a masterpiece. This book is going straight to my best of 2020 list."Music was the feeling of universal understanding." The Treble with Men is a beautiful Phantom of the Opera retelling that is simply unputdownable. Kim Dae, who now goes by the stage name Christine Day, is the quiet fourth chair cellist in the SOOK. The orchestra recently hired a new maestro, the mysterious and masked Devlin is vicious in his teachings and was dubbed by his peers the Devil of the Symphony.When Devlin approached Kim/Christine and asked her to work with him on a new and personal composition she is quite shocked. Why would this brooding man ask her of all people?I'm not going to lie, in the beginning, I had some issues getting over the fact that Devlin was wearing a bandana covering his face at all times. BUT, I swear, once you get over that tiny bit of novelty the story starts to unfold and it's remarkable. As the plot thickens and we get to see Devlin and Kim interacting on a regular basis The Treble With Men becomes absolutely addictive. The pages ooze atmosphere and the dialogues flow easily, going from a hilarious moment to something serious, to a sexual tension so thick you could cut it with a knife.I read My Bare Lady last year, and that was a great book, but you can clearly see here how Piper Sheldon's writing keeps improving. The romance between Kim and Devlin is enthralling, mysterious and seductive. But, we also get to see their vulnerable sides. They are both haunted by their mistakes, and ultimately the journey here is to let go - to forgive yourself and move forward."I think the past is tricky. It shapes so much of who we are. Mistakes, especially. But they're necessary, you know? It's a fine line between learning from them and being indebted to them."One thing that I wanted more from this book: the whole plot with Roddy was a bit shady, it was weird that nobody mentioned the "drink" accident, or persuaded him for more information after the fact. I don't want to spoil anything here, but his actions (especially towards the end of the book) deserved a stronger reprive. Gah, he was just the worst.All in all, it was an honor to read this book. I'm sure it will be one of those that I will read over and over again. It's THAT good.Thank you SO much, Piper Sheldon and Smartypants Romance for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.UPDATE:The Treble with Men is now available on Kindle Unlimited!!!Amazon US: https://amzn.to/38j9pKKAmazon UK: https://amzn.to/2u7p4OmAmazon CA: https://amzn.to/2RAgRKvAmazon AU: https://amzn.to/2NIubeKAppleBooks: https://apple.co/2R1V4MTNook: http://bit.ly/2TJstOiKobo: http://bit.ly/2TJaasuGoogle Play: http://bit.ly/2FYGFun
    more
  • Penny Reid
    January 1, 1970
    ** NOW IN KINDLE UNLIMITED **PEOPLE! You can grab ‘The Treble With Men’ by Piper Sheldon in Kindle Unlimited! WOOT WOOT! I'm so excited GO FORTH AND READ THE THING!** LINKS **Amazon US: https://amzn.to/38j9pKKAmazon UK: https://amzn.to/2u7p4OmAmazon CA: https://amzn.to/2RAgRKvAmazon AU: https://amzn.to/2NIubeK** BLURB **As far as Green Valley is concerned, Kim Dae disappeared into the Wraiths a decade ago. They were sort of right. Kim has spent her life since Jethro fighting her curious nature a ** NOW IN KINDLE UNLIMITED **PEOPLE! You can grab ‘The Treble With Men’ by Piper Sheldon in Kindle Unlimited! WOOT WOOT! I'm so excited GO FORTH AND READ THE THING!** LINKS **Amazon US: https://amzn.to/38j9pKKAmazon UK: https://amzn.to/2u7p4OmAmazon CA: https://amzn.to/2RAgRKvAmazon AU: https://amzn.to/2NIubeK** BLURB **As far as Green Valley is concerned, Kim Dae disappeared into the Wraiths a decade ago. They were sort of right. Kim has spent her life since Jethro fighting her curious nature and trying to blend into the background. Unfortunately for her, a mysterious Maestro comes to town and takes quick notice of her for reasons unknown to anybody.The masked conductor, known simply as Devlin, was already a source of much gossip thanks to his reputation for getting fired. Now, his sudden interest in the quiet fourth chair cellist has added fuel to the rumor fire. The new conductor of the symphony needs to learn to control his temper and finish his latest musical masterpiece and only the reluctant star of his symphony can help him do that. If Devlin can’t convince Kim to help to finish his latest composition he’ll lose everything.Can Devlin and Kim compose without losing composure?
    more
  • DJ Sakata
    January 1, 1970
    Favorite Quotes:Richard Firmin and Andrew Gill were the co-presidents of the SOOK… Nobody else called them Andy-Dick, but as they were a package deal, it was just easier. He pulled his baton from his coat jacket like it was Harry Potter’s wand…“I hate guys like that. Don’t worry. If you want, I'll kick his ass.” He flexed and kissed his biceps. “These guns haven’t lost their bullets.”If you ever tell anybody I screamed like that, they’ll never find your body.I’ll never agree to anything without Favorite Quotes:Richard Firmin and Andrew Gill were the co-presidents of the SOOK… Nobody else called them Andy-Dick, but as they were a package deal, it was just easier. He pulled his baton from his coat jacket like it was Harry Potter’s wand…“I hate guys like that. Don’t worry. If you want, I'll kick his ass.” He flexed and kissed his biceps. “These guns haven’t lost their bullets.”If you ever tell anybody I screamed like that, they’ll never find your body.I’ll never agree to anything without hearing it first. That’s how people end up with a tattoo of a platypus on their ass.Sleep had hit me so hard, I woke up in the same exact position I’d fallen asleep in, wondering what year it was.My Review:I enjoyed this installment twice as much as the first one, it was a wicked funny, multi-faceted, slow-burn romance. The multiple storylines were actively paced and written in my favorite dual POV featuring extremely complicated and oddly fractured characters who were struggling with themselves and each other. Both were ducking for cover from their pasts by using dual personas while doing a rather pitiable job of functioning as either one. They were intelligent people who were living in their heads and essentially emotional and social idiots. I’m curious to see where this series goes next.
    more
  • Smartypants Romance
    January 1, 1970
    You can now grab ‘The Treble With Men’ by Piper Sheldon in #KindleUnlimited! WooHoo! We’re so happy we can make our new Spring Launch releases available to the KU audience while also giving readers on other platforms a chance to grab them, too! Fear not, if you missed TTWM before the KU switcheroo, check back when it comes back out…in about 3 months.** LINKS **Amazon US: https://amzn.to/38j9pKKAmazon UK: https://amzn.to/2u7p4OmAmazon CA: https://amzn.to/2RAgRKvAmazon AU: https://amzn.to/2NIubeK* You can now grab ‘The Treble With Men’ by Piper Sheldon in #KindleUnlimited! WooHoo! We’re so happy we can make our new Spring Launch releases available to the KU audience while also giving readers on other platforms a chance to grab them, too! Fear not, if you missed TTWM before the KU switcheroo, check back when it comes back out…in about 3 months.** LINKS **Amazon US: https://amzn.to/38j9pKKAmazon UK: https://amzn.to/2u7p4OmAmazon CA: https://amzn.to/2RAgRKvAmazon AU: https://amzn.to/2NIubeK** BLURB **As far as Green Valley is concerned, Kim Dae disappeared into the Wraiths a decade ago. They were sort of right. Kim has spent her life since Jethro fighting her curious nature and trying to blend into the background. Unfortunately for her, a mysterious Maestro comes to town and takes quick notice of her for reasons unknown to anybody.The masked conductor, known simply as Devlin, was already a source of much gossip thanks to his reputation for getting fired. Now, his sudden interest in the quiet fourth chair cellist has added fuel to the rumor fire. The new conductor of the symphony needs to learn to control his temper and finish his latest musical masterpiece and only the reluctant star of his symphony can help him do that. If Devlin can’t convince Kim to help to finish his latest composition he’ll lose everything.Can Devlin and Kim compose without losing composure?
    more
  • M.E. Carter
    January 1, 1970
    I mean, it's Piper Sheldon. Of course it's good.
  • Elle's Book Blog
    January 1, 1970
    Release Date: April 7, 2020 Actual Rating: 4 stars Musician Romance I have to admit, the cover for this book (and frankly, the rest of the Smarty Pants Romance novels) are what initially got me to read the books. They are all eye catching, especially the books in the Scorned Women's Society. Anyway, just because a cover is gorgeous that doesn't mean the insides always match. In this case though, they do! This is a great standalone in the series and while I had a hard time connecting with the Release Date: April 7, 2020 Actual Rating: 4 stars Musician Romance I have to admit, the cover for this book (and frankly, the rest of the Smarty Pants Romance novels) are what initially got me to read the books. They are all eye catching, especially the books in the Scorned Women's Society. Anyway, just because a cover is gorgeous that doesn't mean the insides always match. In this case though, they do! This is a great standalone in the series and while I had a hard time connecting with the characters in the beginning, I did grow to love them. This book has some serious undertones and emotion is sewn throughout the story, but the romance is impressive. I love "seeing" the chemistry between characters and it's very real between these two,If you're in the mood for something new this is a great book to chose. Piper Sheldon is doing a wonderful job at bringing her characters to life in these stories and I have been enjoying them immensely.
    more
  • Caitlin Reads
    January 1, 1970
    I was blown away by this novel!! The Treble With Men is easily one of my top reads of 2020 and probably my favorite SmartyPants romance novel yet. I really liked Piper’s writing in her for book but it really escalated in this one. I fell hard for Devlin and Kim/Christine. Both of these characters were trying to move on from difficult things in their past and had a passion for music that brought them together. Their chemistry was undeniable and you could feel their attraction. Phantom of the Oper I was blown away by this novel!! The Treble With Men is easily one of my top reads of 2020 and probably my favorite SmartyPants romance novel yet. I really liked Piper’s writing in her for book but it really escalated in this one. I fell hard for Devlin and Kim/Christine. Both of these characters were trying to move on from difficult things in their past and had a passion for music that brought them together. Their chemistry was undeniable and you could feel their attraction. Phantom of the Opera is my favorite play so I was really excited to read this but didn’t really know what to expect. The Treble With Men went beyond my expectations. I loved the undertone of the Phantom love story. It was also ironic to be reading about a man in a mask when we are all wearing masks now in society. This book was the exact escape I needed from reality at the moment. I couldn’t put it down and read it in less than 24 hours. I also loved catching up with the SWS and can’t wait to read the next book.
    more
  • Nicole Emerald Book Reviews McCurdy
    January 1, 1970
    Emerald Book ReviewsThe Treble With Men by Piper Sheldon‘“All you need to do is watch me.” When he spoke his mask hardly moved; nobody would know he spoke at all. My gaze locked on his as it smoldered with intensity. “It’s you and me.”’When I’m not losing myself in a good book, I can generally be found belting out musical show tunes in my kitchen, because the acoustics in it are amazing and offer me up the illusion that I’m obviously wasted talent, not treading the boards. So when I discovered a Emerald Book ReviewsThe Treble With Men by Piper Sheldon‘“All you need to do is watch me.” When he spoke his mask hardly moved; nobody would know he spoke at all. My gaze locked on his as it smoldered with intensity. “It’s you and me.”’When I’m not losing myself in a good book, I can generally be found belting out musical show tunes in my kitchen, because the acoustics in it are amazing and offer me up the illusion that I’m obviously wasted talent, not treading the boards. So when I discovered author Piper Sheldon was working Phantom of the Opera into her Scorned Women Society series, for Smartypants Romance, my little nerdy heart started beating triple time with excitement, anticipation and expectation.But, let me just stop right here. For the simple fact is, that although I may have watched and sang and lamented over the Phantom too many times to count, author Piper Sheldon has created, imagined, transformed and expanded upon a wonderful, hauntingly familiar storyline, converting it into something profoundly beautiful, soul-stirring, modern and intricate with a breathtaking happy-ever-after. She adds a credible depth to her characters, brings them to life, gives them substance, value and heart. So, although you may *think* you know the tale, let me assure you that Piper has given readers something spectacular and original, that will have you falling in love, hard and fast, within the first chapter. Even those who have never known the story of the Phantom of the Opera, will be charmed and begging for more. Heroine, Christine Day, also known as troubled cellist Kim Dae, was fascinating, I adored and sympathised with her right from the get go. Although the Devil of the Symphony openly hid behind his mask, cloaked himself in darkness, I found the parallels between Kim and he, compelling. Both protagonists were shielding themselves from past mistakes. Two very different people, in the spotlight and behind closed doors. Each of them were hiding in some form or other, isolating and concealing their true selves, living only half lives. Kim held herself accountable for so many things, always striving for perfection, refusing to really feel. Playing her music but not allowing herself to be swept up and moved by it. She was an inferno of passion, trapped behind a glass wall, yet it takes the mystery and provocation of the Devil of the Symphony to break that glass, to push her, antagonise her. For me, the writing here was exceptionally moving, beautifully descriptive and lyrical. How Piper describes the music, the movement, the instruments, the flair and drive that goes behind an orchestra - the music becomes this huge, living, breathing entity and cements itself as the third main character of the book. As Devlin and Kim begin to make music together, letting the swell and emotion of the melodies stir them, both masks start to slip and we are therefore introduced to a more human version of the Devil. Before, in movies and stories, the Phantom is portrayed as an almost exaggerated caricature, like a magic mist, a fable, but in The Treble With Men, Piper Sheldon has humanised him, made him harsh and stoic, shy, funny and sweet. He’s truly captivating and full of layers. Just when you think you have him figured out, another piece is revealed and what you’re left with is a magnificent collage of very real feelings and wants and needs. Devlin is the epitome of a well-written, complex and sexy hero. He will make you mad, have you laughing, sighing, wanting and leave you breathless, because when the man turns on the charm, he turns on the charm. The other side of that coin is, when he hurts, you hurt along with him. Again, being able to extract such an array of emotions from readers, is a gift that every writer wishes they possessed. Piper Sheldon is certainly in possession of some magnificent word magic. ‘I couldn’t let her see how deeply she’d cut me. How much she’d hurt me. That was her song. That was my soul on paper again for her and she wouldn’t accept it.’The writing in The Treble With Men is truly remarkable, sweet and seductive, emotive and powerful- full of passion and rage, hurt and lust and love. It’s also full of great humour, friendship, brotherly love and family. And as always, the ladies of the SWS had me laughing so hard with their banter and support and love for one another. I’m seriously excited for whichever lucky lady is up next, because they all have me invested in their lives and if the next books in the series are written half as well as author Piper Sheldon’s previous, then we’re all in for a very big treat.
    more
  • Curlyhairlass19
    January 1, 1970
    4.75 stars!!If you are looking for a Phantom of the Opera retelling with a unique spin, then Piper’s The Treble with Men is right up your alley. It took me a minute to get into it just due to my scrambled brain at the moment, but I read My Bare Lady last year, and I knew I could trust Piper to take me there. I love seeing her growth as a writer, and she did an amazing job weaving all the mystery, intrigue, sexual tension, and a vulnerability between the characters in a real way. I love how both 4.75 stars!!If you are looking for a Phantom of the Opera retelling with a unique spin, then Piper’s The Treble with Men is right up your alley. It took me a minute to get into it just due to my scrambled brain at the moment, but I read My Bare Lady last year, and I knew I could trust Piper to take me there. I love seeing her growth as a writer, and she did an amazing job weaving all the mystery, intrigue, sexual tension, and a vulnerability between the characters in a real way. I love how both characters learn to forgive and move on from past mistakes. I don’t want to spoil anything because there are some things, trust me. I just love what SmartyPants Romance is doing showcasing these amazing authors, and giving them a chance to let their writing light shine! Bravo!
    more
  • Piper Sheldon
    January 1, 1970
    The SWS is back! Kim and Devlin are ready to rock your world!
  • Sheila'S Book Corner
    January 1, 1970
    The Treble With Men is SO GOOD! I completely fell in love with the smart, funny and just slightly quirky heroine. The story pays homage to The Phantom Of The Opera with it’s own Devil Of The Symphony, the mysterious mask-wearing, Maestro Devlin. “Devlin had a brother? Why did this information come as such a shock to me? It conflicted with the image I had of him as a solitary grump that sprung from the earth and dwelled in the cold basements of buildings.” As a gifted cellist, Kim Dae was heading The Treble With Men is SO GOOD! I completely fell in love with the smart, funny and just slightly quirky heroine. The story pays homage to The Phantom Of The Opera with it’s own Devil Of The Symphony, the mysterious mask-wearing, Maestro Devlin. “Devlin had a brother? Why did this information come as such a shock to me? It conflicted with the image I had of him as a solitary grump that sprung from the earth and dwelled in the cold basements of buildings.” As a gifted cellist, Kim Dae was heading towards Juilliard and a bright musical future until her plans derailed. After a stint in rehab she changed her name to Christine Day, moved back with her parents and toned down her life.“I grayed out until I faded into the background. I toned down and tuned out. That was fine. I was fine. I was existing. Until now.” Each Smartypants Romance is a standalone. Christine/Kim’s friends in the Scorned Women’s Society make appearances but with no spoilers and we do get a cameo by a certain reformed bad boy Winston brother. ;) This story is one of my favorites and I plan to grab the audiobook for a reread. -5+ Stars!--Diane-
    more
  • Antonella
    January 1, 1970
    3,5 stars I still adore that all of Jethro's ex-girlfriends have a club...This is my favorite spin-off idea for a series!!
  • zaira
    January 1, 1970
    "Everything that led us to this moment was worth it. If I had to stay away a hundred years just for five minutes of your time, I'd take whatever I could get." Love this Phantom of the Opera retelling from Piper Sheldon!Devlin - the masked conductor - wears a mask to hide himself and to avoid making connections with people. He has this great composition he's working on but he needs the help of Kim to make it happen.Kim Dae - who now goes by Christine Day in an attempt to put distance from her "Everything that led us to this moment was worth it. If I had to stay away a hundred years just for five minutes of your time, I'd take whatever I could get." Love this Phantom of the Opera retelling from Piper Sheldon!Devlin - the masked conductor - wears a mask to hide himself and to avoid making connections with people. He has this great composition he's working on but he needs the help of Kim to make it happen.Kim Dae - who now goes by Christine Day in an attempt to put distance from her past - is a very talented cellist but she tends to hide herself. The guilt she feels from what happened in the past has marred her reality. When she's playing the cello, she holds back because she doesn't want to be in the spotlight. In the words of Devlin, "You [Kim] went from this bright, ambitious cello player to this grayed-out shape of a person."Devlin knows she is capable of more. When Kim lower her guards down, that is when her passion shines through while she's playing. He helps her gain more confidence and he keeps reminding her that while it's okay to have fears and guilt from the past, she needs to learn to let go in order to grow. They grow closer as they work on Devlin's composition together during their weekend practices.It warms my heart seeing Kim rekindle her passion for playing the cello!! The way Piper Sheldon writes about the scenes with the music made me feel the emotions pouring out from the pages.I love that both Kim and Devlin have a good and supportive family!! It's nice to see their different family dynamics and they definitely added to the fun moments in the book. There's a conversation between Kim and her parents right around the end of the book that has so many good life lessons. Growth is seen through Kim and Devlin as they learn to accept and let go of their past. It's also seen with the Scorned Women's Society (the SWS), Kim's friend group who came together out of anger at first but turned into this healthy friendship filled with love and support for each other. Now that we've got Suzie's (My Bare Lady) and Kim's story, I can't wait for the rest of the ladies!A bonus in this book: that cameo from one of the Winston brothers <3 ARC provided by author.
    more
  • Cassandra Martin
    January 1, 1970
    This book is a retelling of the Phantom of the Opera, and Piper pulled it off flawlessly. The love for music in this book, it spoke to my soul. I can say with certainty, this book will be a top book of 2020 for me. This story was THAT well written, these characters are THAT amazing. I love how Kim talks about how exes shouldn't be grouped together to compare to the new relationship. That's unfair to both the exes, and the new relationship. I was full on cheering, YES!There is so much chemistry b This book is a retelling of the Phantom of the Opera, and Piper pulled it off flawlessly. The love for music in this book, it spoke to my soul. I can say with certainty, this book will be a top book of 2020 for me. This story was THAT well written, these characters are THAT amazing. I love how Kim talks about how exes shouldn't be grouped together to compare to the new relationship. That's unfair to both the exes, and the new relationship. I was full on cheering, YES!There is so much chemistry between Devlin and Kim, it just jumps off the pages. Kim was not confident in her choices, due to her previous bad choices - which was completely understandable, those choices landed her in rehab. Both Devlin and Kim had some major hurdles to overcome, and those hurdles were from their own past. By letting go of the past, their own failures, learning their lessons, but moving on, they were able to end that cycle of self doubt. And Jethro - I love how he is still getting redeemed from his past, even now in Piper's books, with each of his exes. You'll have to read the book to find it, but absolutely worth it. I loved the ladies of the Scorned Women's Society, can't wait to see who's book is next!Now Available on Kindle Unlimited!!
    more
  • Ashley
    January 1, 1970
    It takes a great deal of bravery to take on the world's most popular musical and retell it as contemporary romance. Author Piper Sheldon rises to that challenge and delivers her own, beautiful work of art in 'The Treble with Men,' which is easily one of the best books of 2020.I could feel, and almost hear, the music coming out of the pages, an amazing testament to Sheldon's skill with the written word. I couldn't set this book down and simultaneously never wanted the story to be over. It flowed It takes a great deal of bravery to take on the world's most popular musical and retell it as contemporary romance. Author Piper Sheldon rises to that challenge and delivers her own, beautiful work of art in 'The Treble with Men,' which is easily one of the best books of 2020.I could feel, and almost hear, the music coming out of the pages, an amazing testament to Sheldon's skill with the written word. I couldn't set this book down and simultaneously never wanted the story to be over. It flowed well, had good pacing, wonderful characters and an engaging story.*****The Treble With Men, an all-new standalone contemporary romance from Piper Sheldon, is LIVE! As far as Green Valley is concerned, Kim Dae disappeared into the Wraiths a decade ago. They were sort of right. Kim has spent her life since Jethro fighting her curious nature and trying to blend into the background. Unfortunately for her, a mysterious Maestro comes to town and takes quick notice of her for reasons unknown to anybody.The masked conductor, known simply as Devlin, was already a source of much gossip thanks to his reputation for getting fired. Now, his sudden interest in the quiet fourth chair cellist has added fuel to the rumor fire. The new conductor of the symphony needs to learn to control his temper and finish his latest musical masterpiece and only the reluctant star of his symphony can help him do that. If Devlin can’t convince Kim to help to finish his latest composition he’ll lose everything.Can Devlin and Kim compose without losing composure?‘The Treble with Men’ is a full-length contemporary romance, can be read as a standalone, and is book #2 in the Scorned Women’s Society series, Green Valley World, Penny Reid Book Universe.See more at kindledsouls.wixsite.com/bookblog
    more
  • Amanda (Romance Reviewed)
    January 1, 1970
    (ARC REVIEW) This is the story of two people (Maestro and hidden-virtuoso) who have to learn to take of their masks (literal and figurative) in order to truly understand how to love and be loved in returned. The book is laid out much like one of Devlin's compositions, with soaring highs and devestating lows, all held together with love, family, bits of humor, and pent up emotions. You do have to suspend belief just a little over the masked "devil of the symphony" situation but once you get over (ARC REVIEW) This is the story of two people (Maestro and hidden-virtuoso) who have to learn to take of their masks (literal and figurative) in order to truly understand how to love and be loved in returned. The book is laid out much like one of Devlin's compositions, with soaring highs and devestating lows, all held together with love, family, bits of humor, and pent up emotions. You do have to suspend belief just a little over the masked "devil of the symphony" situation but once you get over that its smooth sailing. Green Valley was only a minor character this time, but we did get a Jethro scene so it's always a plus when a Winston stops by. Highly recommended- 4.5/5 stars!Full blog tour with excerpt: https://romancereviewed.com/2020/04/2...
    more
  • Erica Testa
    January 1, 1970
    The Treble with MenI do not even know where to begin with this romance. I also do not feel like it’s out of line to state that this is one of the best novels I’ve read in the last year, if not, many years. I must preface this review- I’ve never actually seen the “Phantom of the Opera” (blasphemy, I know!), but I know the general gist. This story is a lose re-telling with a twist, but it is absolutely unique and the characters are incredible. Our heroine is Kim Dae (stage name Christine Day), the The Treble with MenI do not even know where to begin with this romance. I also do not feel like it’s out of line to state that this is one of the best novels I’ve read in the last year, if not, many years. I must preface this review- I’ve never actually seen the “Phantom of the Opera” (blasphemy, I know!), but I know the general gist. This story is a lose re-telling with a twist, but it is absolutely unique and the characters are incredible. Our heroine is Kim Dae (stage name Christine Day), the only child of older parents and a member of the Scorned Women Society. She plays the Cello in the SOOK. Kim is recovering from brokenness and trying so hard to just stay safe. This ultimately means she’s not truly living her life. Her past, while heartbreaking, is also inspiring.Our hero, the Devil of the Symphony is Devlin. He wears a mask and keeps his own brokenness close to his chest. These two together are everything. Two broken people trying to figure out the world and overcome their pasts. Kim’s blunt honesty and fears made for such an enticing heroine. You want her to win. You are rooting for her from the get go. Her inner monologue and even the things she says aloud to Devlin had me laughing out loud at times. Her friends at the SWS are the same inspiring women we have come to love (and I cannot wait to read more of these women’s stories). Devlin is someone who keeps any emotions that are non-combative tucked closely to himself, and you get to see him slowly open up himself. He is brusque and you just know deep down there is a man who needs acceptance and love. He is simultaneously tough to love and such a swoony hero. You want him to win her heart. He has a family that I wish was my family (and I am blessed with one of the great ones). They are open and honest and loving and it’s everything you love to read for a broken hero. The sexual tension was, I mean like FIRE. It was slow, burning, and there were multiple moments where I was like “maybe this is it?” only for it to be drawn out a smidge more, but not in a frustrating way at all. It was necessary for their scars and the professional boundaries they were trying to maintain. When they come together, you just know. This is it. This is love.This was hands down one of the most touching, riveting stories I’ve read in years. This is the third book by Piper Sheldon that I’ve had a hard time setting down. I went about my day, my tablet in hand, until it was complete. I don’t even know where to go after this book. If I could give it 6 stars, I would. Smartypants Romances continue to raise the bar on what it means to be a “smart romance”, and I truly look forward to every single release.
    more
  • Izzie d
    January 1, 1970
    This is part of the Smartypants romance series which is connected to the Winston brothers series by Penny Reid.This series is based on the ex girlfriends of Jethro Winston.Good story.Well written.Grumpy Hero.No intimate scenes other than the Hero and heroine.Small other man drama and small history revealed between Jethro and the heroine.HEA.
    more
  • Jessica Alcazar
    January 1, 1970
    WOW Look, I don’t know how it happened, but these two totally sucked me in! I know the story behind the Phantom of the Opera. I mean who doesn’t, right? But this was fresh and new and even more exciting. There were times throughout this book that I questioned my knowledge LOL That’s the spin the author put on the story. It was glorious! I loved it! WELL DONE!
    more
  • Michelle
    January 1, 1970
    In a time when I couldn’t concentrate on anything, this book had me riveted. Kim and Devlin both started off as great mysteries, and as we slowly learned their backstories and their connections, I loved them even more. As two characters that were hiding so much from themselves and others that they couldn’t even use their real names, it was wonderful to experience their growth as individuals and a couple in the book. Stripping off the masks, both figuratively and literally, they love each other i In a time when I couldn’t concentrate on anything, this book had me riveted. Kim and Devlin both started off as great mysteries, and as we slowly learned their backstories and their connections, I loved them even more. As two characters that were hiding so much from themselves and others that they couldn’t even use their real names, it was wonderful to experience their growth as individuals and a couple in the book. Stripping off the masks, both figuratively and literally, they love each other in the most fundamental way. I feel like Piper’s quote “Exterior beauty was never a good indication of the quality of content inside.” Is such a mantra for the entire Smartypants Romance series, and so fitting here. Piper’s writing makes you feel like you are actually there, living the story, and not just reading it. She describes a stormy night and it’s so visceral, you get a little scared, and then she throws in some levity like “I screamed. We both screamed ... but there was no ice cream.” And, everything is ok again. I loved the connection back to the women of SWS and how their friendships are so enduring. And, I liked the how Jethro popped in for some redemption at the end too. I’m glad, because I like him. Great characters, great story, great series. Can’t wait to see whose story is next in the SWS.
    more
  • Nikki Becker
    January 1, 1970
    My first thought after finishing this book was “Oh my heart!!!” The second thought was “I MUST READ THIS BOOK AGAIN!” Admittedly, I’m a huge fan of this author, the other two books she has out right now were great reads and i loved them. So my expectations were already high for this book. Piper Sheldon took those expectations and blew them out of the water! This book.....this book is everything!! The love, the music, the emotion, the life lessons...all so beautifully written and wrapped up in a My first thought after finishing this book was “Oh my heart!!!” The second thought was “I MUST READ THIS BOOK AGAIN!” Admittedly, I’m a huge fan of this author, the other two books she has out right now were great reads and i loved them. So my expectations were already high for this book. Piper Sheldon took those expectations and blew them out of the water! This book.....this book is everything!! The love, the music, the emotion, the life lessons...all so beautifully written and wrapped up in a gorgeous package (this book cover?? COME ON!!!). This book will leave you satisfied with the best book hangover ever. I can safely say this is one of my all time favorite reads to date.
    more
  • Diane (Books and Tequila Blog)
    January 1, 1970
    The Treble With Men is SO GOOD! I completely fell in love with the smart, funny and just slightly quirky heroine. The story pays homage to The Phantom Of The Opera with it’s own Devil Of The Symphony, the mysterious mask-wearing, Maestro Devlin. “ The realization that this was in fact a bathroom sunk in as I belatedly registered that a person stood hunched over the sink, gripping the basin, head hanging. Not just any person. A painfully sexy, naked, male person. Let me repeat that for those in t The Treble With Men is SO GOOD! I completely fell in love with the smart, funny and just slightly quirky heroine. The story pays homage to The Phantom Of The Opera with it’s own Devil Of The Symphony, the mysterious mask-wearing, Maestro Devlin. “ The realization that this was in fact a bathroom sunk in as I belatedly registered that a person stood hunched over the sink, gripping the basin, head hanging. Not just any person. A painfully sexy, naked, male person. Let me repeat that for those in the back. Naked man. Standing nakedly without clothes on his undressed figure … bare. The man who was my Maestro, and composer. YUP. That one.”-5++ Stars!!- My full review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
    more
  • Angie Reed
    January 1, 1970
    Kim was trying to piece her life back together one day at a time but lived in constant fear. Devlin had his own fears as well. Add in their connected pasts as well. What a great book about letting go, trusting yourself and living! Loved these two found each other!!
    more
  • Emily Neilsen
    January 1, 1970
    I just have no words. I was having a hard time concentrating but this book pulled me into it immediately and I adored it. Kim and Devlin are brought to life brilliantly by Piper Sheldon. I just loved this book so very much. I cannot wait for more in this series and I just recommend everyone read this as soon as you can.
    more
  • Elaine
    January 1, 1970
    Piper Sheldon a I've have never laughed and cried so hard in my life!! This book has to go in my top 10 books of the year!!
  • Viviana Varona
    January 1, 1970
    I received an ARC for an honest opinion.It was a beautiful story and it had some wonderful life lessons within it. I definitely recommend this book, this series, and this author.
  • Diana Tucker
    January 1, 1970
    Just Keep Playing! Oh my - so many feels in this book. At first I’m like why the mask - this is kinda weird. In full disclosure, and at risk of outing myself, I’ve never scene the Phantom of the Opera. Yes I’ve been living under a rock! Or something. But Piper Sheldon did such an amazing job bringing the emotion and passion of this book’s characters to life that I can see why so many people do embrace the magic of musicals. Piper also did an amazing job playing homage to role that Jethro played Just Keep Playing! Oh my - so many feels in this book. At first I’m like why the mask - this is kinda weird. In full disclosure, and at risk of outing myself, I’ve never scene the Phantom of the Opera. Yes I’ve been living under a rock! Or something. But Piper Sheldon did such an amazing job bringing the emotion and passion of this book’s characters to life that I can see why so many people do embrace the magic of musicals. Piper also did an amazing job playing homage to role that Jethro played in Kim’s life and I absolutely loved how she linked Jethro in the story’s conclusion. I loved this book. Another solid win in the SmaryPants world of winners. I can’t wait for more goodness from Piper and all the amazing SmartyPants writers.
    more
  • Sarah Keffer
    January 1, 1970
    4.5 stars! I loved this book! I went into it blind, knowing nothing of the story, only that I knew I had to read it because I loved this author's first book in this series My Bare Lady. Devlin is a mystery from the start, as he wears a mask/bandana to conceal his identity and he seems angry, cold and distant. Kim is just trying to do her job...play her cello, keep to herself and not garner any special attention. But she is drawn to the mysterious Devlin and when he asks her for help with a speci 4.5 stars! I loved this book! I went into it blind, knowing nothing of the story, only that I knew I had to read it because I loved this author's first book in this series My Bare Lady. Devlin is a mystery from the start, as he wears a mask/bandana to conceal his identity and he seems angry, cold and distant. Kim is just trying to do her job...play her cello, keep to herself and not garner any special attention. But she is drawn to the mysterious Devlin and when he asks her for help with a special project, she agrees. I fell hard and fast for Devlin, he is the quintessential mysterious bad boy. I really like Kim as well but I wanted to shake her a few times, so that she would wake up and see her worth and make her own decisions. But as the story progressed, I came to realize why she leaned so heavily on her old friend, Roddy, and loved seeing her realize that things that happened in the past weren't her fault and be able to move past it. There are a couple special scenes featuring our old friend from The Winston Series, Jethro, which I loved. This book is sexy, has love, heartbreak and healing and the ending is just perfect! I highly recommend this book!
    more
  • Amy Dickinson
    January 1, 1970
    Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“‘I think the past is tricky. It shapes so much of who we are. Mistakes, especially. But they’re necessary, you know? It’s a fine line between learning from them and being indebted to them […] But you can’t let it hold you prisoner. It was just a lesson, not a life sentence.'”You know when you read a book that you love to your toes, and you become so effusive about it that it overwhelms the words for your review? Well, this reader/blogger is there. To say that I’m incre Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“‘I think the past is tricky. It shapes so much of who we are. Mistakes, especially. But they’re necessary, you know? It’s a fine line between learning from them and being indebted to them […] But you can’t let it hold you prisoner. It was just a lesson, not a life sentence.'”You know when you read a book that you love to your toes, and you become so effusive about it that it overwhelms the words for your review? Well, this reader/blogger is there. To say that I’m incredibly impressed with Piper Sheldon is an understatement. When I read the first book of her Scorned Women Society series for SmartyPants Romance, My Bare Lady, I appreciated two facets of it: her reworking of the My Fair Lady story and her sense of her self as a writer. I enjoyed that book, titillated by the fact that she chose one of my favorite stories to retell in the context of Penny Reid’s Winston Brothers universe. However, there were a few moments in her story that felt a little slow. I had a grand appreciation for that book, but I wouldn’t say that I would gush profusely over it. Then, she wrote The Treble with Men. And I’m done. This second book of her Scorned Women Society series is exponentially better than My Bare Lady. It is a treatise on control. Some of us struggle with embracing the message behind the popular Disney film, Frozen, in “letting go” of life, embracing the moments to connect and improve and feel a passion for life. This is the essence of The Treble with Men. Sheldon nestles this lesson within the world of Reid’s Tennessee and the world of music. Even more, like her My Bare Lady, she utilizes the vehicle of The Phantom of the Opera story to give it life. In doing so, she reimagines this oft-loved tale with a different ending, one that feels wildly better than the original. All of these attributes conspire to scream at the ingenuity of Sheldon’s storytelling. It is all of this and more that should compel you to “one-click” this book.“I’d shown her my love in the lessons. In the music. I could tell her everything. I could tell her the truth of my love for her, but then what? It would still be me choosing for her. She needed to make a choice about her own life. I wouldn’t be another person telling her what to do. I wouldn’t hamper her growth. I loved her too much.”What is it about The Treble with Men that makes it worthy of your time and energy? Here’s the list:*At the most basic level, Piper Sheldon has the best cover of the SmartyPants Romance world. Bar none. *Her retelling of The Phantom of the Opera is done in such a way to challenge our notions about the original. For many of us, the ending of that story is bittersweet, as we want Christine to choose the Phantom, but she doesn’t. <<(view spoiler)[>> Sheldon’s Kim Dae does, and it’s glorious. It suggests that the seemingly most difficult character of a story can also be loved. That’s the heartbreak of the original: that the Phantom is unworthy of love because he isn’t offered up in a neat pretty package. With Sheldon’s story, Devlin, the “phantom” character, hides behind a constructed persona as a defense and for good reason. As the reader, you empathize with him, and Sheldon allows us to do so because Kim (Christine Day) is never truly frightened by him; she is intrigued. She sees him better than everyone else in the story. Sheldon offers us an initial lesson that “nothing is ever as it seems,” and we, as human beings, should look deeper for a greater understanding: something missing from OG Phantom of the Opera. This, right here, magnifies Sheldon’s genius as the author of this story.*The characters are compelling. Both Kim and Devlin are fighting for control of their lives. Kim does so at the expense of the depth of her talent. Thankfully, Devlin “sees” her (just as she fully “sees” him), and he challenges her control. As he encourages her to embrace her passion, this allows Devlin to feel his. These two drive each other forward, propelling them to greater heights, including their chemistry and eventual love for each other. Their feelings of lust and love heighten Sheldon’s story, and it engages the reader more deeply into the book’s pages.*Secrets always make for greater suspense. The Treble with Men is a book of secrets. Both Devlin and Kim are holding onto them tightly. I won’t divulge anything here, as I don’t want to spoil the book for readers. What I want to do is give a nod to Sheldon’s use of it to build the tension of her book. Sometimes, stories divulge their secrets too quickly, and the pacing and depth of the book are lost. Sheldon suspends her readers for the right length of time that you find yourself enraptured in her story because you can’t wait to see how the secrets upend the lives of the characters. Since those secrets aren’t divulged until later in the story, this book becomes one that you simply can’t put down. Even after we know Devlin and Kim’s secrets, there is fall-out from them that keeps you engaged. Sheldon has paced this perfectly to grab the attention of her readers until the last page.*And probably one of the most important aspects of this book is its diversity. For one, it is set in the world of music. Kim is a cellist, while Devlin is the conductor. There aren’t many romances written in this world, creating an interesting space to inhabit for the story. Secondly, Kim is a POC. As such, she doesn’t “look” like your average heroine. At a time when diversity is necessary for romance, I love this choice. Even more, while Kim is a driven perfectionist, this doesn’t read as a stereotype; instead, it suggests that it is a personality trait of Kim’s. Sheldon’s choice for her heroine feels important in our world.I believe I have gushed enough over Piper Sheldon’s The Treble with Men enough. From its cover to its title to its characterizations to its storytelling, this book is another example of what SmartyPants Romance is doing right. It’s opening a world to more voices. In doing so, Penny Reid gives us new authors with new voices that need to be heard. Sheldon’s story is an important one because it reminds us that there is freedom in living our truth and our passions. We shouldn’t work so hard to control every aspect of our lives because we miss out on the prismatic colors of it. Devlin and Kim come to this understanding, and Sheldon’s story finds even greater heights. If you love the re-telling of a favorite story, then you will definitely love Piper Sheldon’s The Treble with Men. I know I did. (hide spoiler)]
    more
  • Azraa
    January 1, 1970
    Thank you to the publisher for kindly providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Another cute small town rom com from the Green Valley Universe that will show you a new side of their small town yet remind you of the warm and tender parts that you know of it and love! 1. Our protagonist Kim Dae who now goes by Christine Day is a sweet, shy, strong, emotional and beautiful fourth chair cellist in the symphony of Knoxwille. She loves her job as it allows her to do the one thing she Thank you to the publisher for kindly providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Another cute small town rom com from the Green Valley Universe that will show you a new side of their small town yet remind you of the warm and tender parts that you know of it and love! 1. Our protagonist Kim Dae who now goes by Christine Day is a sweet, shy, strong, emotional and beautiful fourth chair cellist in the symphony of Knoxwille. She loves her job as it allows her to do the one thing she cherishes most that is playing music. She is super passionate regarding it yet not overly ambitious as she doesn’t want to become a first chair cellist, doesn’t want any spotlight, just wants to play music without taking anyone’s notice. She has a past of which she isn’t proud. She is also highly indecisive.2. Despite Kim’s best attempt to hide, the new mysterious Maestro finds her easily in the crowd. When Devlin listens to Kim play her cello, he is instantly mesmerised and he knows immediately she is what he is looking for and what he wants and needs to compose his symphony and have Kim play it at the fall showcase. Devlin is your average grumpy, stoic and ill tempered hero who likes perfection and isn’t afraid to show people their place when they aren’t respecting him. He is notorious for being fired from all his previous job and he is sure it’s only a matter of time till he leaves Green Valley. But before he does he wants to perform the show of his lifetime and for which he needs Kim’s help. 3. Soon the two find common ground and start working to help Devlin compose his symphony. Music has always meant something important for me. There are people whose lives have never been affected by it which didn’t make sense to me as music holds a great power over me to drown me in it. Other than reading, it is the one thing that gets me high. I loved the way it was described in the book giving you the feel of listening to it while reading about it. Kim’s passion for her music and Devlin’s ambitions were all very well defined and gave a beautiful depth to the story as well as the characters. 4. Their relationship quickly goes from being of a cellist and Maestro to that of a friendship. They connect over their love for music and their past in a profound way. Devlin makes an effort to know and understand Kim and Kim wants to peel all his layers and get to know him too. Devlin does make the decision for Kim to help him as she couldn’t do it herself but also giving her a way out so she doesn’t feel forced.5. The important issues were treated with utmost care with just enough attention that they needed. The scene where Kim talks about how women are generally categorised into groups and how WRONG that is really spoke to me. I loved how she spoke in favour of not disrespecting Devlin’s ex and respecting them for being separate people with good and bad both. Trash talking is really overrated and Piper Sheldon is having none of it. 6. The side characters were all so varied and played a good role in the book. Kim and Devlin’s relationship with their respective parents was narrated with beauty showing the eminence of parent’s role in one’s life. Both of their relationships with their parents were completely different yet same in the way as they both were full of affection and support for their children.7. Overall I enjoyed it a lot and Piper Sheldon has done a beautiful job of writing a book with small town feels, passion and heartwarming relationships. The plot has a steady pace and things played out very well in the end. There were parts I laughed out loud (the Devlin’s house corridor scene) and parts where I cried from happiness (at Jethro’s cameo because I love him). Will definitely be looking forward to the next book in the series while binge reading all the other books from the author.
    more
Write a review